The Bachelorette 10 - *Final 1-F2* - Speculation * Sleuthing - Spoilers Thread #2

Continue Final 1 Final 2 speculation here.

I just went back and listened/watched the videos from RS of Nick on the plane.
I havent listened to them since he released them. After watching 4 episodes now, I am more convinced than ever that Nick is definitely the F2, and Josh the F1. If that was a set up, Nick is a dang good actor. What he was saying about Josh fits what I have seen so far (temper, competitive). I think they were real. How the person recognized him is still amazing to me, but I do believe the videos are the real deal. Also, if Nick were F1, he wouldn't have been returning home that early.

nutty1 wrote:I just went back and listened/watched the videos from RS of Nick on the plane.
I havent listened to them since he released them. After watching 4 episodes now, I am more convinced than ever that Nick is definitely the F2, and Josh the F1. If that was a set up, Nick is a dang good actor. What he was saying about Josh fits what I have seen so far (temper, competitive). I think they were real. How the person recognized him is still amazing to me, but I do believe the videos are the real deal. Also, if Nick were F1, he wouldn't have been returning home that early.

ITA! Is this a first for us, girl?? We've only been watching this together for like 8 years        

:Woah-hoo: :Woah-hoo: :Woah-hoo:

PS….I have become a huge JP and Ashely fan!!

nutty1 wrote::Woah-hoo: :Woah-hoo: :Woah-hoo:

PS….I have become a huge JP and Ashely fan!!

Cupcakes for all!!!

Apologies, back to your regularly scheduled Meeeeendi talk now.

nutty1 wrote:I just went back and listened/watched the videos from RS of Nick on the plane.
I havent listened to them since he released them. After watching 4 episodes now, I am more convinced than ever that Nick is definitely the F2, and Josh the F1. If that was a set up, Nick is a dang good actor. What he was saying about Josh fits what I have seen so far (temper, competitive). I think they were real. How the person recognized him is still amazing to me, but I do believe the videos are the real deal. Also, if Nick were F1, he wouldn't have been returning home that early.

Okay, I know my wild speculation game is back at it, but what IF Nick was F2, Josh was F3 and HE came back and interrupted Andi/Nick on a LCD. Wouldn't that be enough for Nick to be bitter with Josh??

Again, I know...wild speculation, but for some reason that video is still giving me major red flags so trying to figure out how it all fits.

Yep, wild speculation!   

nutty1 wrote:Yep, wild speculation!   

So from your perspective that just couldn't happen? I ask as I am wondering what I am missing with that video. Thanks for your input.

Aunties_Love wrote:

nutty1 wrote:Yep, wild speculation!   

So from your perspective that just couldn't happen?  I ask as I am wondering what I am missing with that video.  Thanks for your input.

I think one point made with regard to the video was the date/timing of it.  If Nick is F1, he supposedly wouldn't be on the final leg plane ride home but rather still on location with Andi on that date.

Aunties_Love wrote:

nutty1 wrote:Yep, wild speculation!   

So from your perspective that just couldn't happen?  I ask as I am wondering what I am missing with that video.  Thanks for your input.

First, I don't think Chris is the F1 guy. He's not being shown enough, IMO.
Also, I do think Josh wouldn't have been the main subject if he was F3. I think Nick sounded like a guy who just got dumped and was feeling that initial sting and of course, a bit of animosity toward the F1 guy, Josh.

nutty1 wrote:

Aunties_Love wrote:

nutty1 wrote:Yep, wild speculation!   

So from your perspective that just couldn't happen?  I ask as I am wondering what I am missing with that video.  Thanks for your input.

First, I don't think Chris is the F1 guy. He's not being shown enough, IMO.
Also, I do think Josh wouldn't have been the main subject if he was F3. I think Nick sounded like a guy who just got dumped and was feeling that initial sting and of course, a bit of animosity toward the F1 guy, Josh.

You're right, the timing was wrong. He would have stayed a few days with Andi on location after the filming was done. And for it to be a fake video, we have to ask 2 questions: What would he gain by agreeing to do it? Just to prove that RS was wrong? Would he put his integrity on the line for MF?

And if Josh was not the F1, I'd imagine they'd want him as the next Bachelor, and would they really have Nick trash talk him on a video they were going to release?